FUBAR.
A military acronym that stands for ( lets use the sanitized
version ) [Fouled] Up Beyond All Recognition. Apparently Fubar originated back in WW2 and is slang (mangled German)
for the word "Furchtbar"
which means terrible
or horrible. When it comes to the current state of the healthcare system,
terrible or horrible just don’t do it justice. The healthcare system is, in my opinion,
FUBAR.
As a physio for almost 24 years I have been through the
healthcare trenches, and seen many changes. I mean, when I started EMR wasn’t
even thought of! We were scribbling notes out and writing out charges. In PT
school I may have touched a computer once. I literally had to photocopy ( 10
cents a page) every article I wanted to read! In short, … I’m old!
We have made incredible progress over the years in our
profession with some amazing clinicians developing and progressing the
profession. However at the same time we, collectively (PTs, MDs, admins,
politicians, insurance companies – the medical industry) have completely failed our patients. Sure ,
there are amazing stories of innovation, we are saving more people from
maladies that would have killed them years ago, we are transplanting organs,
performing surgeries only once dreamed of, and many people are living healthy
lives in the western world. Yet at the same time, when we look in at the
experience of the patient, our client, the person right in front of us that has
come to us for help it is a frightening tale of failure.
This really rang true to me this week with a couple of
patient encounters. The saddest part is that these two stories are not rare in today’s
system. I guess I should have written this earlier. I don’t know why it has
struck me now to speak out… maybe I’m just getting into my grumpy old PT mode
as I age…. Or maybe healthcare is getting worse.
Patient 1: A middle aged gentleman. Referred by an
orthopedic doctor with the diagnosis of “tennis elbow.” He tells me his pain
started a month ago when he was turning a stuck valve and felt a pop. He has
had increased pain since. He tried OTC meds without relief and it got to the
point that picking up objects was painful and really affecting his work and
home life. He saw an MD and, of course with
NO alternate options on their mind for musculoskeletal pain, went through a
month of NSAIDS, then injections- all with no relief. After a follow up visit in a month it (for
some reason) occurred to the MD that a referral to physiotherapy may be
appropriate. If it persisted, imaging was the next stop (MRI).
On a brief evaluation he had pain and tenderness at the
radio humeral joint and pain with resisted supination. No real pain with any
resisted wrist motion, no radial nerve signs and an otherwise clean exam. After
a manipulation of the radial head and soft tissue work and dry needling to the
supinator he reported instant relief.
Lets look at a few of the multiple problems here:
1) The same insurance paid the physician 4x as much as they
paid for my service – TWICE. Then paid for medications, and steroid injections,
and almost an MRI.
2) This man spent a month in pain affecting his work and
family life all based on a diagnosis that really appears to be wrong.
3) Taking NSAIDS (which did not help) can have significant
effects on the GI system and as was recently highlighted by the FDA heart
attack and stroke risk increase even with short-term use, and the risk may
begin within a few weeks of starting to take an NSAID. Furthermore, steroid
injections are also not without risks and side effects.
Patient 2: An 81 year old gentleman who comes for
evaluation for chronic back pain. He has had pain on and off since his twenties
which has become constant and severe. Reviewing the history I see that he has
had an implanted spinal stimulator, injections, has been on opioids and has
been followed by “pain management” for years. He recently had his opioids cut
back. Sixty years of pain (30 of them bad by patient report), this wasn’t
exactly an eval I was excited to be a part of. Yet when I went in the room I
was met by a pleasant and kind man who explained that he was primarily
frustrated because his pain is limiting him from caring for his wife who is
suffering from dementia and needs almost around the clock care and supervision.
He had placed her in an assisted living center but when he
went to visit found she was not receiving good care and he wanted better for
her – thus bringing her back home. He is doing everything at home and even
obtained a bed alarm that alerts him when she gets up at night and wanders. She
had once wandered out of the house alone in a confused state. He also reports that
he is no longer able to sleep well.
I went through my eval and did discover some issues I felt
we could address physically - significant loss of hip and knee mobility,
hypomobility through the lumbar spine and significant trunk and hip weakness to
highlight a few. Along with the obvious need for pain neuroscience education I
felt that we could definitely help this man, at least to some degree. The most
shocking part of my evaluation is when he told me he had not seen PT before. He stated that he was “tired of going
from medication to medication and having injections” and continuous procedures.
He literally said, “I feel like exercise and moving is what I need.”
This gentleman had been stuck
for decades in the medical industrial complex being pushed from one med to
another, one intervention to another, and obtaining no relief. He underwent
procedures that had risks and side effects and was taking numerous meds and
opioids with all of their risks. At no point did anyone actually place their
damn hands on the man and assess his movement. At no point in all these years
was therapy suggested. At no point was he provided education on pain to
decrease catastrophizing and fear avoidance behavior.
I was dumbfounded. We, collectively as a medical system and
as a society, have failed this man. I believe that even after all these years
he can improve. However, think of the
possibilities if he had been managed differently all these years. How would
that affect his life now? How would that affect his wife’s life now? We will
never know what could have been but I do know it could have been better.
I want to be clear that I do not write this so as to place
blame on other providers and elevate my abilities. I mess up on a daily basis.
I don’t make the right decisions on treatment every time I see a patient. I
don’t always address psychosocial issues as much as I should. I don’t always
progress and develop my treatments as well as I should. We are all human. Almost
all medical providers have nothing but the best of intentions. However they are
often stuck in a system that is FUBAR.
I know I can do better. I know we can all do better. We need
to do all we can to get our voices out there and let everyone know that we are
the alternative to meds, imaging and surgery. I am so grateful for so many voices
in our profession that have begun to speak over the noise and bring forward
thinking solutions and promoted the profession like never before.
@timothywflynn , @jeffmooredpt, @theaphpt, @dr.mitch.dpt, @ryansmith.dpt,
@updocmedia, @theducklegs, and of course @physio.praxis (Just to name a few)
Physical Therapists are the answer to so many of our systems
issues. We owe it to our patients to work on being a solution and not another
cog in an out of control system.
